When a criminal case ends with a conviction or a sentence, it can seem like the door has closed. However, Wisconsin law provides a way for people to challenge what happened in the courtroom. Two of the most common options are a criminal appeal and a sentence modification, and people are not quite sure which one applies to their situation.

Both processes involve going back to the court system after a judgment has been entered. Both can potentially change your outcome. But they operate under different legal standards and target different problems. If you or someone you care about is weighing post-conviction options, contact the law firm of Martinez & Ruby LLP Attorneys At Law in Baraboo, Wisconsin. Our experienced criminal defense lawyers will explain your options, whether it be a sentence modification or a criminal appeal. 

What Is a Criminal Appeal, and When Does It Apply?

A criminal appeal is a formal request asking a higher court to review what happened at the trial level. You are arguing that something went legally wrong during the proceedings, and that the error affected the outcome in a meaningful way. 

Situations like improper jury instructions, evidence that should have been excluded but wasn’t, prosecutorial misconduct, or ineffective assistance of counsel are the kinds of errors that may support an appeal. The law does not guarantee a successful appeal simply because a mistake occurred. The error generally needs to be significant enough that it may have influenced the jury verdict or the sentence.

In Wisconsin, a person with a conviction generally has the right to pursue a direct appeal to the Wisconsin Court of Appeals. If that court rules against you, there may be an option to ask the Wisconsin Supreme Court to weigh in, though the Supreme Court has discretion over which cases it accepts. The process is structured and sequential, and missing a step can seriously limit your options. Also, Wisconsin law generally requires that certain post-conviction motions and notices be filed within specific and short timeframes after sentencing. 

What Is a Sentence Modification, and Is It Right for Your Case?

With a sentence modification, you are not arguing that the trial itself was flawed. You are going back to the circuit court, the same court that sentenced you, and asking that judge to reconsider the length or conditions of the sentence that was imposed.

Wisconsin law generally provides two ways a defendant can pursue sentence modification. One approach involves arguing that the original sentence was excessive, unduly harsh, or otherwise an improper exercise of the court’s sentencing discretion. This type of motion typically needs to be filed within a relatively short window after sentencing. The other approach involves presenting what Wisconsin courts refer to as a “new factor,” meaning information that was highly relevant to the sentencing decision but was not known to the judge at the time the sentence was handed down because it did not yet exist or was unknowingly overlooked by all parties.

This new factor cannot be simply new to you. It needs to be something that, had the judge known it at the time, would have meaningfully affected how the sentence was structured. Post-sentencing behavior, including rehabilitation efforts and good conduct, does not on its own rise to the level of a new factor. 

And, even when a new factor is established, that does not automatically mean the sentence gets reduced. The circuit court still has discretion over whether a modification is warranted. Two people presenting similar circumstances can get very different results depending on the judge and the specific facts involved.

How Do These Two Processes Differ in Practice?

An appeal goes upward in the court system to the next level of judges. If the issue to be challenged on appeal was not previously raised in the circuit court, such as ineffective assistance of counsel, the first step is a postconviction motion filed in circuit court. If the court denies the motion, then that denial can be appealed to the court of appeals. If the issue was something the circuit court already ruled on during trial, such as a motion to exclude evidence, then it can be appealed directly without the need for a postconviction motion. By contrast, a sentence modification motion must always go back to the originating court. 

An appeal is asking a higher court to find that the lower court got something legally wrong. A sentence modification is asking the same court that sentenced you to reconsider based on either a procedural argument about how the sentence was calculated or new information that changes the picture.

If the conviction itself is the problem, if something went wrong during the trial or the legal process leading up to it, a criminal appeal is likely the more appropriate avenue. If the conviction stands but the sentence feels disproportionate or there is genuinely new information that the sentencing judge never had, sentence modification may be worth exploring.

In some cases, both avenues may be worth evaluating. Knowing which path to follow should become clear after you have talked with an attorney who is highly experienced with both.

Contact Us To Identify Your Best Option

At Martinez & Ruby LLP Attorneys At Law, we work with clients across Wisconsin who are navigating these decisions, and we understand how much is riding on getting it right. If you have questions about your post-conviction options, contact us to schedule a consultation with one of our experienced lawyers.