Wisconsin Criminal Appeal Lawyer

Home » Services » Criminal Appeals
Mistakes or intentional misconduct in the courtroom can lead to wrongful convictions. Existing flaws in the justice system should not result in your future being tarnished and your rights being violated. The existence of higher courts allows for a review of possible legal errors that occurred in trial courts. If you have been wrongfully convicted, it is paramount to stand up to the criminal justice system alongside experienced criminal appeal lawyers.

Experienced Criminal Appeal Lawyers Taking Action Against Your Wrongful Conviction

Martinez & Ruby, LLP, is one of the top two appellate firms in Wisconsin. Our defense team has litigated and won post-conviction matters across the state for a wide variety of criminal charges, including those for drug, sexual, and violent convictions. If you’ve been convicted of a crime and want to appeal, you need to call the criminal appeals law firm of Martinez & Ruby, LLP.

Our appellate team has earned a well-deserved reputation for securing successful outcomes for clients. We have a strong track record of overturning convictions and getting charges dismissed outright.

Past results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future case. Every case depends on its own facts, record, and law. The matters below are a selection of past cases and are not a complete list of every case handled. A new trial, resentencing, or plea withdrawal is not an acquittal; in many cases, the charges remained pending afterward.

Selected cases, most recent first. Client names withheld.
Year County Conviction / Charges Issues Raised Result
2026 Juneau Five counts of child sexual assault. The direct appeal, handled by other counsel, was denied. Motion for a new trial under Wis. Stat. § 974.06:
  • Jury instructions violated the right to a unanimous verdict
  • Trial counsel was ineffective for failing to object and failing to present key impeachment evidence
  • Prior appellate counsel was ineffective for failing to raise these issues
The circuit court denied the motion. The Wisconsin Court of Appeals reversed and granted a new trial.
2026 Sheboygan Third-degree sexual assault Sentencing judge relied on inaccurate information, violating the client's due process rights. The court agreed and granted resentencing.
2026 Polk Child enticement; sentenced to prison
  • Prosecutor breached the plea agreement
  • Plea counsel gave erroneous advice
  • Client's reliance on that advice invalidated the plea
The court found the plea was not knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently entered because of the erroneous advice, and granted plea withdrawal.
2025 Sheboygan Second-degree sexual assault (use of force) The State failed to disclose police reports and body-camera video that would have impeached the accuser's credibility. New trial granted. The judge found the nondisclosure of exculpatory evidence violated the client's due process rights.
2024 Portage Armed robbery, false imprisonment, battery, and other charges
  • Trial court improperly excluded key defense evidence
  • Trial counsel made numerous errors, including failing to call witnesses supporting the client's innocence
State courts denied the appeal. On a federal habeas petition, the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin granted a new trial, finding constitutional violations and that the Wisconsin Court of Appeals' contrary findings were unreasonable.
2024 Dodge Attempted homicide Sentencing judge relied on inaccurate information, violating the client's due process rights. State courts denied the appeal, finding any error harmless. On a federal habeas petition, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin granted a new sentencing hearing, finding the error was not harmless and that the Wisconsin Court of Appeals applied the law unreasonably.
2023 Marathon Six counts after a jury trial, including repeated sexual assault, child enticement, and causing a child to view sexual activity
  • Court erroneously excluded important defense evidence
  • Prosecutorial misconduct
  • Trial counsel was ineffective for failing to present evidence of the accuser's motive to lie and failing to object to improper testimony
The judge found trial counsel ineffective, vacated the convictions, and granted a new trial.
2023 Lafayette Second-degree sexual assault of an intoxicated victim, after a jury trial
  • Excluding the client's testimony about what the accuser said before and during the incident violated his right to present a defense
  • Prosecutor improperly presented evidence of the client's pretrial refusal to give a statement to police
The judge agreed on both grounds, vacated the conviction, and granted a new trial.
2022 Milwaukee Two counts of reckless injury and possession of a firearm by a felon, after a jury trial, despite another witness's testimony admitting to the shooting
  • Trial counsel was ineffective for failing to present testimony from a victim whose description of the shooter matched the defense witness
  • Trial counsel inadequately challenged the credibility of the State's key witness
The judge agreed on both grounds and vacated the convictions.
2022 Walworth Five counts of cocaine delivery and one count of heroin delivery, after a jury trial Postconviction investigation uncovered text messages indicating someone else was supplying the drugs. Motions for a new trial based on the State's failure to disclose exculpatory evidence, newly discovered evidence, and ineffective assistance of counsel. The prosecutor conceded the motions and agreed to reopen and dismiss the cocaine charges and impose time served on the heroin charge. The client was released from prison.
2022 Jefferson First-degree reckless homicide (alleged heroin delivery resulting in an overdose death), after a jury trial Postconviction investigation uncovered evidence linking another suspect. Motions for a new trial based on the State's failure to disclose exculpatory evidence, ineffective assistance of counsel, and newly discovered evidence. The judge agreed and granted a new trial.
2021 Brown Child abuse
  • Trial court excluded evidence of the accuser's prior violent acts
  • Trial counsel failed to file appropriate motions regarding that evidence
The judge found the evidence was improperly excluded in violation of the client's constitutional right to present a defense, and granted a new trial.
2020 Adams Repeated sexual assault of a child, after a jury trial Trial counsel was ineffective for failing to present evidence challenging the accuser's credibility. State courts denied the appeal. On a federal habeas petition, the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin vacated the conviction and granted a new trial, finding trial counsel ineffective and that the Wisconsin Court of Appeals applied the law unreasonably.
2020 St. Croix Three counts of attempted homicide, three counts of reckless injury, three counts of reckless endangerment, and felon in possession of a firearm, after a jury trial
  • Erroneous admission of expert testimony demonstrating racial bias and improperly commenting on witness credibility
  • Prosecutorial misconduct referencing that testimony in closing argument
The Wisconsin Court of Appeals granted a new trial.
2019 Dane Third-degree sexual assault, false imprisonment, and battery
  • Court erroneously admitted improper character evidence
  • Prosecutorial misconduct during the first trial
New trial granted.
2019 Winnebago OWI (3rd offense), after the circuit court denied a motion to suppress Evidence was obtained after law enforcement unlawfully entered the curtilage of the client's home. (Attorneys Ruby and Meyer-O'Day) The Wisconsin Court of Appeals reversed the conviction and ordered suppression of all evidence obtained after the unlawful entry. The State later dismissed the charges.
2018 Adams Arson
  • Ineffective assistance of prior counsel
  • Prosecutor failed to disclose exculpatory evidence
New trial granted. The State chose not to retry the case, and the charges were dismissed.
2018 Trempealeau Charged with child sexual assault Prosecutorial misconduct; retrial barred by double jeopardy. All charges dismissed.
2017 La Crosse Sexual exploitation of a child and possession of child pornography Postconviction investigation uncovered evidence supporting the client's innocence. New trial granted. The State chose not to retry the case, and the charges were dismissed.
2017 Milwaukee Substantial battery The prosecutor failed to disclose two statements by the alleged victim stating the client was innocent. The Wisconsin Court of Appeals granted a new trial. The State chose not to retry the case, and the charges were dismissed.
2017 Dane Second-degree sexual assault Ineffective assistance of prior counsel. New trial granted. The case was later resolved as non-sexual-assault misdemeanors.
2016 Columbia Charged with attempted first-degree intentional homicide, strangulation and suffocation, battery, and disorderly conduct, all as domestic abuse Charges were barred by double jeopardy. The Wisconsin Court of Appeals agreed, and all charges were dismissed.
2016 Dane Recklessly endangering safety Ineffective assistance of prior counsel. New trial granted.
2016 Vernon Stalking Court improperly admitted prejudicial evidence. New trial granted.
2016 Columbia Child enticement (guilty plea) Ineffective assistance of prior counsel. The circuit court allowed the client to withdraw his guilty plea.
2014 Dane First-degree recklessly endangering safety Ineffective assistance of prior counsel. New trial granted.

These summaries describe the issues raised and the court's ruling in each matter. They are not a guarantee, warranty, or prediction of the outcome of any other case. Contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Do I Have a Valid Appeal?

This is one of the most common questions people ask after receiving an unfavorable verdict or sentence. The honest answer is that not every conviction qualifies for a successful appeal, but many do, and the only reliable way to know whether yours does is to have an experienced appellate attorney review the full record of your case. Understanding what courts look for when evaluating an appeal can help you recognize whether something may have gone wrong in your trial or sentencing.

A criminal appeal is not a second trial. You cannot simply argue that the jury got it wrong or that you are innocent. Instead, appellate courts review the trial record for legal errors, constitutional violations, or other identifiable problems that may have affected the outcome of your case. Common grounds for a valid appeal in Wisconsin include the following.

  • Ineffective assistance of counsel. If your trial attorney failed to investigate key evidence, neglected to call important witnesses, made critical errors during plea negotiations, or otherwise performed below the standard expected of a competent defense lawyer, you may have grounds to challenge your conviction. Under the standard established in Strickland v. Washington, you must show both that your attorney’s performance was deficient and that the deficiency prejudiced the outcome of your case.
  • Improper admission or exclusion of evidence. If the trial court allowed evidence that should have been suppressed, such as evidence obtained through an unlawful search or seizure, or excluded evidence that should have been presented to the jury, that error may provide a valid basis for appeal.
  • Prosecutorial misconduct. Prosecutors are bound by strict ethical and legal obligations. If a prosecutor withheld favorable evidence, made improper statements during closing arguments, or engaged in other misconduct that influenced the jury’s verdict, those actions can form the basis of a strong appellate argument.
  • Insufficient evidence to support the verdict. If the evidence presented at trial was legally insufficient to support a guilty verdict on one or more charges, an appellate court may overturn the conviction on those counts.
  • Incorrect jury instructions. Jurors decide cases based on the legal instructions given to them by the judge. If those instructions misstated the law or omitted a required element of the charged offense, the resulting verdict may be legally defective.
  • Sentencing errors. Even if the underlying conviction stands, you may have valid grounds to challenge the sentence imposed. Sentencing errors can include a court’s reliance on inaccurate information, misapplication of sentencing guidelines, or imposition of a sentence that exceeds what the law permits.
  • Newly discovered evidence. In some post-conviction proceedings, evidence that was not available at the time of trial and that could not have been discovered through reasonable diligence may support a motion for a new trial.

Deadlines Matter in Wisconsin Criminal Appeals

Wisconsin imposes strict deadlines on criminal appeals. In most cases, a notice of intent to pursue post-conviction relief must be filed within 20 days of sentencing. Missing that deadline can severely limit your options, and in some circumstances, it can foreclose your right to appeal entirely. If you were recently convicted or sentenced, acting quickly is not just advisable, it is essential.

Contact Our Criminal Appeals Law Firm For Your Criminal Appeal

Appellate litigation is an unfamiliar practice area to a majority of lawyers. Attorney Cole D. Ruby is universally known as one of the top appellate attorneys in Wisconsin and serves as a primary source for the state’s legal community in appellate litigation. Mr. Ruby’s successful representation has been repeatedly recognized by Super Lawyers, and he has presented on appellate issues at the State Public Defender’s annual conference and conferences sponsored by the Wisconsin Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (WACDL).

If you believe there has been a mistake in your case, contact us for a free initial consultation: 608-355-2000 or fill out our intake form. Guarding your future is important when so much is at stake. Martinez & Ruby, LLP, is located in Baraboo, Wisconsin, but our criminal appeal attorneys practice throughout Wisconsin.